Duck.ai vs Venice AI vs Proton Lumo is the comparison people reach for when they want a ChatGPT alternative that does not keep a file on them. The three names get grouped together, but they solve different problems. Duck.ai hides who you are from the model provider. Venice lets you choose how much of the inference step is locked down, and it leans into fewer content limits. Proton Lumo runs open models on its own European servers and encrypts the history it saves. Each one wins a category.
Disclosure: this page is published by Secret Chat AI, which competes in the same space and is not affiliated with DuckDuckGo, Venice or Proton. Our own head-to-heads are on the comparisons page. Competitor facts below come from each company's own pages, checked on October 5, 2026. For how long other chatbots keep what you type, see our 2026 AI chatbot data retention audit.
Duck.ai vs Venice AI vs Proton Lumo at a Glance
| Criterion | Duck.ai | Venice AI | Proton Lumo |
|---|---|---|---|
| How privacy works | Proxy: IP address and personal metadata removed before the prompt reaches the provider | Four modes: Anonymous, Private (default), TEE and E2EE | Open models on Proton's own servers; saved chats under zero-access encryption |
| Account | None needed | Free plan with sign-up | Guest mode; Proton Account for saved history |
| Models | Small GPT and Claude models, Mistral, gpt-oss and Gemma free; larger GPT and Claude models on Plus and Pro | Uncensored open-source models, plus GPT, Claude, Gemini and Grok depending on the mode | Open models such as Qwen, GLM and Apertus, picked per task |
| Where history lives | On your device; optional end-to-end encrypted Sync & Backup | In your browser, not on Venice's servers | On Proton's servers, zero-access encrypted; guest sessions erased |
| Images | New Image tool with follow-up edits | Generation and editing, upscaling, background removal | Image creation and analysis |
| Video | Not documented | Yes, on Pro and above, paid with credits | Not documented |
| Content limits | No filtering by DuckDuckGo; each provider's policy applies | Uncensored open models; some models keep their own limits | Not marketed as uncensored |
| Files | Images and PDFs on some models; no spreadsheets | Documents up to 10 MB in chat | File uploads for summaries |
| Open source | Not stated | Offers open-source models | Lumo's code is open source |
| Plans | Free with a daily limit; Plus and Pro subscriptions | Free, Pro, Pro Plus, Max | Lumo Free and Lumo Plus |
Duck.ai: Anonymous Chat With the Least Setup
Open duck.ai and type. There is no account. DuckDuckGo removes your IP address and other personal metadata before the request reaches the model provider, and its contracts bar those providers from training on your chats. The providers agree to delete prompts and replies once the answer is returned. The stated exceptions are short prompt caching at OpenAI and Anthropic, up to an hour and never written to disk, and Anthropic keeping chats where the law requires it or to fight misuse.
The free models are the small ones: Claude Haiku, GPT mini and nano, Mistral Small, plus gpt-oss and Gemma hosted by Tinfoil inside a trusted execution environment. Plus and Pro subscribers get the larger GPT and Claude models and higher limits. Chats stay on your device by default, and the free Sync & Backup can carry them across devices with end-to-end encryption.
The weak spots are depth and media. The free tier is capped daily, PDF uploads are limited by page count, spreadsheets are not supported, and there is no video. Images work through the New Image tool, and you can ask for changes in follow-up messages. Choose Duck.ai if you want quick, free, anonymous chat and nothing else.
Venice AI: Uncensored Models and a Privacy Dial
Venice sells itself on uncensored open-source models and creative work. It also has the widest media range of the three: image generation and editing, upscaling, background removal, and video on Pro and higher plans, paid with credits. Its pricing page lists Grok Imagine, Seedance and Kling among the video models.
Read the privacy mode, not the brand. Venice's own page says that in Anonymous mode, which reaches GPT, Claude and Gemini, your identity is hidden but "you should assume the provider is storing your content." Private mode, the default, runs on Venice-controlled GPUs or zero-retention partners and relies on contracts saying no prompt or reply is stored. TEE mode runs inference inside hardware-isolated enclaves from outside partners. E2EE encrypts the prompt on your device until it reaches a verified enclave. Those two modes come with the Pro plan, fewer models and slower replies, and E2EE drops web search and memory. History stays in your browser.
So the strongest inference-time protection on this page belongs to Venice, but only in TEE and E2EE. Saying "I use Venice" does not tell you what happened to a given prompt. Its FAQ also notes that individual models keep their own built-in limits, so uncensored does not mean every model answers everything. Choose Venice if fewer refusals and video matter, and you are willing to set the mode on purpose.
Proton Lumo: Encrypted History on European Servers
Lumo is Proton's approach to AI chat. It runs open models, named as Qwen, GLM, Apertus and image models, on Proton-controlled servers in Europe, so no outside model provider appears in the chain. Saved chats sit under zero-access encryption, Proton says it keeps no logs of your conversations, and Lumo's code is open source. Chats are not used for training, apart from optional anonymized feedback you choose to give.
It covers the everyday jobs: answers with optional web search, file uploads, translation, writing, coding help, and image creation and analysis. Guests can chat without an account, and those sessions are erased afterwards. Lumo Free has limited messages, a 7-day history and one Project. Lumo Plus raises the limits and adds unlimited Projects.
The trade-off is the model bench. Lumo does not offer GPT, Claude or Gemini, and it does not document video. Choose it when keeping one accountable European operator in charge of the whole chain matters more to you than frontier models.
Where Secret Chat AI Fits
Venice comes closest to a one-stop shop, but it keeps video behind a subscription, and none of the three documents a panel of models checking each other or generators that hand you a finished file. That is the gap Secret Chat AI aims at. It has two image entries: Standard Image with GPT Image, Nano Banana and Grok Imagine, and the uncensored Image generator (listed as Image Lax, with a flame) with Seedream, Qwen Image, Lustify and WAI Illustrious, plus an Upscaler. The video generator works the same way: Video with Kling, Veo and Grok Imagine Video, and uncensored Video Lax with Wan, Seedance and MiniMax. Clips run up to 30 seconds or up to 4K, depending on the model. See the image generator for the picture side.
Chat covers ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, DeepSeek USA, GLM Abliterated and Perplexity. Grok, DeepSeek USA and GLM Abliterated run at the Uncensored level, a lighter screen than a standard chatbot's, meant for fiction, satire, dark themes, clinical and political work. Sexual content involving minors, terrorism and real threats of violence are blocked on every model, and each provider keeps its own rules, so a request can still be refused. The uncensored AI guide has the details. The AI Council sends one question to two, three or four models and has a referee map where they disagree.
The privacy model is narrower than Lumo's, and we say so. We keep no chat archive on our side, build no profile, and never use your material for training. But every prompt, picture and document goes verbatim to the model provider, so remove names and sensitive details before you send. If no cloud provider may see a prompt at all, run a local model instead; Secure AI Gateway vs Self-Hosting weighs that choice. Secret Chat AI removes you from your queries — it does not remove the data from your messages. You pay as you go from a dollar balance: packs start at $12, there is no subscription, and the balance never expires.
Verdict by Use Case
| You want… | Pick |
|---|---|
| Free, anonymous chat with no account and no setup | Duck.ai |
| Fewer refusals for fiction or research, plus video, in one subscription | Venice AI |
| Hardware-enforced protection at the inference step | Venice AI, in TEE or E2EE mode |
| Encrypted saved history and one European operator running the models | Proton Lumo |
| Frontier models, many image and video models and an Uncensored level, without a subscription | Secret Chat AI |
| Several models checking one answer, with the disagreements laid out | Secret Chat AI's AI Council |
For head-to-heads with each of the three, read Secret Chat AI vs Duck.ai, Secret Chat AI vs Venice AI and Secret Chat AI vs Proton Lumo.