Secret Chat AI vs Proton Lumo comes down to who runs the model. Lumo is Proton's assistant. It runs open models on servers Proton controls, keeps saved chats under zero-access encryption, and now draws and edits pictures too. Secret Chat AI is a single app for the big commercial models, image and video generators, an Uncensored level and the AI Council. Your request goes to the provider of the model you pick, and we keep no chat archive of our own.
If nobody outside one company should process your prompt, Lumo is the better pick. If you need video, more model families or several models checking each other, Secret Chat AI covers more ground. Secret Chat AI is not affiliated with Proton or any model maker named here.
Secret Chat AI vs Proton Lumo at a Glance
| Criterion | Proton Lumo | Secret Chat AI |
|---|---|---|
| Models available | Open models from the Qwen, GLM and Apertus families, run on Proton-controlled servers; Lite and Max models with Fast and Thinking modes | ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, DeepSeek USA, GLM Abliterated and Perplexity |
| Image generation | Create, edit and analyze images, including sketch-to-image; limited on Free, more on Plus | Image and Image Lax entries with 10 image models and an Upscaler |
| Video generation | None documented | Video and Video Lax entries with 10 video models |
| Uncensored level | No separate level documented; terms forbid illegal content and harassment | Uncensored chat, image, video and Duet entries, marked with a flame |
| AI Council | One assistant answers; no multi-model referee documented | Duet, Trio, Quartet and Duet Lax: several models answer, a referee compares their claims |
| Document generators | Writing, translation, summaries and coding help in chat; Projects and Custom Lumos | 11 work generators that build presentations, charts, tables, documents, resumes, emails and more as files |
| Account and registration | Guest mode without an account; Proton account to save chats | Free daily quota without an account; paid use needs an email and password, no name or phone |
| Chat history storage | Saved on Proton servers with zero-access encryption for signed-in users; guest chats erased at session end | In your browser only; no server-side chat archive, no sync between devices |
| Training use | Not used for training, except Apertus feedback you choose to submit | Never used for training |
| Pricing model | Free plan with limits; Lumo Plus subscription; Lumo for Business | Small free daily quota, then pay as you go from a prepaid dollar balance; no subscription, the balance never expires |
AI Image Generation: Both Draw, Only One Makes Video
Lumo draws now. Since its latest major update you can type a prompt and refine the picture in the same conversation, edit an uploaded image, or turn a sketch into a picture. Proton says pictures you upload and pictures Lumo makes are stored so that not even Proton can open them. The free plan caps image generations; Lumo Plus gives more.
Secret Chat AI treats pictures as their own tool, with a choice of models. The Standard Image generator offers GPT Image, Nano Banana and Grok Imagine. The uncensored Image generator is listed as Image Lax, with a flame, and offers Seedream, Qwen Image, Lustify and WAI Illustrious. Models differ in edits, resolution, transparent backgrounds, style presets and how many variants come back at once. The Upscaler sits in both lists. The price shows before you generate, and a failed picture costs nothing.
Video is where the two part ways. Proton's Lumo pages describe pictures only. Secret Chat AI has a Standard Video generator and an uncensored one listed as Video Lax. Between them they cover Kling, Veo, Grok Imagine Video, Wan, Seedance and MiniMax. You can start from text, from a first frame, or from a first and last frame on models that support it. Clips run up to 30 seconds, resolution goes up to 4K on Veo, and most models can add sound.
Chat Models: Open Models or Commercial Families
Proton lists the models behind Lumo: open models from the Qwen, GLM and Apertus families, plus open image models for drawing and editing. Lumo picks the one it judges best for each request, and you choose between Fast and Thinking modes. Its latest major update also added stronger web search with cited sources, a Memory feature and Custom Lumos with your own instructions.
Secret Chat AI puts seven chat families in one picker: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, DeepSeek USA, GLM Abliterated and Perplexity. Most have Smart Agentic, Fast Chat, Web Search and Research modes. You can switch model in the middle of a chat, and the whole conversation goes to the new one. There is an overlap worth knowing about. Lumo also runs a GLM model. Ours, GLM Abliterated, is Abliteration AI's uncensored version of the open GLM model, and it can search the web, read pictures and documents, and draw.
Uncensored AI and the Safety Floor
Proton does not describe an uncensored mode for Lumo. Its terms bar illegal content, including child sexual abuse material, and harassment, and they accept users from age 13. That is a reasonable default for a general assistant.
Secret Chat AI labels two moderation levels. Standard uses a stricter screen. Uncensored uses a much lighter one, meant for fiction, satire, dark themes, political work and clinical questions. Grok, DeepSeek USA and GLM Abliterated carry the flame, as do Image Lax, Video Lax and Duet Lax. Some limits never move: sexual content involving minors, terrorism and real threats of violence are blocked on every model. Each provider also keeps its own rules, so a request can still be refused. Expect fewer needless refusals, not a system with no rules. The uncensored AI guide explains the levels.
AI Council and Work Generators
With Lumo, one assistant answers. The AI Council sends one question to several models from different companies at once. A Duet uses two, a Trio three, a Quartet four. A referee then marks which model asserts, contradicts or ignores each claim, builds a synthesis from claims at least two models share, and lists what to verify. The free Duet pairs DeepSeek with ChatGPT. Duet Lax pairs GLM Abliterated with Grok under the Uncensored level. Agreement between models is evidence, not proof; disagreement is the useful signal.
Lumo writes, translates, summarizes and helps with code in chat, and it can work with files from Proton Drive. Secret Chat AI adds 11 work generators that hand you a file: presentations, charts, tables, documents, resumes, emails, translations, rewrites, articles, social posts and logos. Add Image and Video and you have the full set. If a reply in chat is all you need, Lumo is simpler. If you need a deck or a spreadsheet to download, the generators save the copy-and-paste.
Private AI Chat: Two Different Designs
Proton's design keeps everything in one company. The models run only on servers Proton controls. Prompts are encrypted so only Lumo's GPU servers can decrypt them, and Proton says the data is erased once the answer is generated. Saved chats use zero-access encryption, which means Proton cannot read them. The code is open source, and the service is based in Europe under GDPR. You can even reach it through Tor as a guest.
Secret Chat AI makes three promises and no more. We store no chat archive on our side; your history lives in your own browser. We build no profile and link no chat to you, so providers see our service rather than you. Your material is never used for training.
Now the limit. Every prompt, picture and document goes verbatim to a third-party provider such as OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, xAI or Abliteration AI, and OpenAI's moderation classifier sees what is screened. We do not control what happens there, and a provider may keep data under its own terms. Remove names and sensitive details before you send. Secret Chat AI removes you from your queries; it does not remove the data from your messages. On this point Lumo's single-operator setup is the stronger one, and it is fair to say so.
Subscription or Pay as You Go
Lumo has a free plan with limited messages, history, image generations and Max model use, plus one Project. On the free plan, saved chats are kept for 7 days. Lumo Plus is a subscription that raises those limits and unlocks unlimited Projects; Lumo for Business serves teams.
Secret Chat AI gives a small free daily quota for the fast tiers of ChatGPT and Claude, DeepSeek USA, Perplexity and the free Duet. Beyond that you add a prepaid US-dollar balance through Volet, in crypto or by card through a Volet wallet. Packs start at $12, and you can enter a custom amount. No subscription is sold, and the balance never expires. See pricing for the details.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Proton Lumo if the model has to run on its operator's own hardware, if you want your saved history under zero-access encryption, or if open-source code and native iOS and Android apps matter to you. It also suits people who already live in Proton Mail and Proton Drive.
Choose Secret Chat AI if you want video as well as pictures, a wider model bench, an Uncensored level, the AI Council and work generators, all on one balance that never expires. You can also compare it with Duck.ai and Venice AI, or see all AI comparisons.